20% OFF when you spend $350+ Discount in Cart | Empowering Women % Sales Donated | Shop Gifts For Her 20% OFF when you spend $350+ Discount in Cart | Empowering Women % Sales Donated | Shop Gifts For Her

Home / Collections / Jewelry Gifts Under $500

Jewelry Gifts Under $500

Shopping for Fine Jewelry Gifts Under $500 that arrive gift ready with Free Shipping? You've come to the right jewelry store for your gift shopping. Shop for jewelry gifts within your budget and Shop by Price! A new feature and we are constantly adding new pieces by budget category. Use our Drop-A-Hint button to share your dream pieces with your gift giver!

Sort by:

Inside of Leatherette Jewelry Box Travel Case With Mirror

Leatherette Jewelry Box Travel Case With Mirror

$68.99

Our Wanderlust Jewelry Travel Case Organized AF Jewelry Wallet Genuine Leather shown in Luscious Carmel

Wanderlust Jewelry Travel Case Organized AF Jewelry Wallet Genuine Leather

$79.99

Hinged Hoop Huggie Earrings in 14K Yellow Gold in Blue Sapphire Ruby and Diamond Styles in Model's Hand

Hinged Huggie Hoop Earrings Natural Blue Sapphire in 14K Rose Gold

Hinged Huggie Hoop Natural Diamond, Sapphire or Ruby Earrings Solid 14K White Rose Yellow Gold

from $415.99

Birthday Suit Bezel Set Diamond Adjustable Bracelet in Solid 14K Yellow Gold

Birthday Suit Bezel Birthstone Natural Citrine Adjustable Bracelet in 14K Yellow Gold

Birthday Suit Bezel Birthstone Adjustable Bracelet 14K Yellow White Rose Gold or Sterling Silver

from $102.99

A great everyday stud earring collection by Vintage Magnality

.06 CTW Diamond Single Initial J Earring 14K Yellow Gold Ethical Sustainable Fine Jewelry Storyteller by Vintage Magnality

Natural Diamond Single Stud Initial Earring A-Z Solid 14K Yellow Gold

from $282.99

Gothic Diamond Initial Charm Pendant shown with Birthstone Diamond Charm Pendant

Diamond Gothic Initial K Charm Pendant 302® Fine Jewelry Storyteller by Vintage Magnality

Gothic Initial (A-Z) Natural Diamond Charm Pendant 14K Yellow or White Gold

from $250.99

Model wearing diamond initial bracelet 302® Fine Jewelry Storyteller by Vintage Magnality

Natural Diamond Initial M Adjustable Bracelet in Solid 14K White Gold

Natural Diamond Initial A-Z Adjustable Bracelet Solid 14K White Gold

from $313.99

Diamond Initial Earring with other studs by Vintage Magnality

Natural Diamond Single Initial T Earring in 14K White Gold

Natural Diamond Single Initial Earring A-Z Solid 14K White Gold

from $282.99

Scorpio Zodiac Charm Pendant on our Faceted Bead Solid 14K Gold Chain Necklace

.85 MM Faceted Bead Gold Chain Necklace or Bracelet Solid White 14K Gold

.85 MM Cable 7" Bracelet to 24" Chain Necklace with Faceted Beads Solid 14K Rose White Yellow Gold

from $245.99

Moon Phase Bar Pendant 14K Yellow Gold .0075 CTW Diamond 302 Fine Jewelry Storyteller by Vintage Magnality

Moon Phase Natural Diamond Bar Pendant in Solid 14K Yellow Gold

Moon Phase Natural Diamond Bar Pendant 16-18" Necklace 14K Yellow White Rose Gold or Silver

from $91.99

A Collection of stud earrings by Storyteller Wear Everyday Jewelry by Vintage Magnality

Celtic Trinity Natural Diamond 1/10 CTW Stud Earrings in 14K Yellow Gold

Celtic Trinity Natural Diamond 1/10 CTW Stud Earrings Solid 14K Rose Yellow White Gold or Silver

from $462.99

Model wearing our heart chain necklace

Have a Heart 14K Yellow Gold Chain 7" Bracelet 9" Anklet 16" Necklace by Vintage Magnality

Have A Heart Solid 14K Gold Chain 7" Bracelet 9" Anklet 16" 18" Necklace

from $374.99

Uppercase Block Letter A Initial Pendant Necklace 16" Solid 14K White Gold or Sterling Silver

Block Uppercase Letter Initial Necklace 16" Solid 14K Yellow White Gold or Sterling Silver

from $81.99

Rope Chain Necklace 1.25 MM with Lobster Clasp in 14K Yellow Gold

Rope Chain Necklace 1.25 MM with Lobster Clasp in 14K White Gold or Sterling Silver

Rope Chain Necklace 1.25 MM Lobster Clasp Solid 14K Yellow White Rose Gold or Sterling Silver

from $39.99

Figaro 1.28 MM Chain Bracelet or Necklace in 14K White Gold

Figaro 1.28 MM Chain 7" Bracelet 16" 18" 20" 24" Necklace 14K White Yellow Rose Gold

from $196.99

Model wearing Petite Key Bracelet 14K Yellow Gold

Petite Key Adjustable Bracelet in 14K Yellow Gold

Unlock Your Dreams Petite Key Adjustable Bracelet Solid 14K Gold, Platinum, or Silver

from $74.99

Model wearing our Be A Boss Natural or Lab-Grown Diamond Stackable Ring in 14K Yellow Gold

1/10 CTW Diamond Stackable Ring 14K White Gold Ethical Sustainable Fine Jewelry Storyteller by Vintage Magnality

Be A Boss Natural or Lab-Grown Diamond Stackable Ring Solid 14K White Rose Yellow Gold

from $437.99

Initial Charm Necklaces in 14K Yellow Gold

Petite Natural Diamond Initial Pendant Adjustable Necklace Initial A in 14K Yellow Gold

Petite Natural Diamond Initial 16-18" Necklace (A-Z) 14K Yellow White Rose Gold

from $478.99

Diamond Stackable Ring in 14K White Gold by Vintage Magnality

.06 CTW Natural Diamond Stacking Ring in 14K White Gold

.06 CTW Natural Diamond Stacking Ring Solid 14K White Rose Yellow Gold

from $431.99

Evil Eye Heart Charm Pendant 14K Yellow Gold

Evil Eye Heart Charm Pendant 14K Yellow Gold

Evil Eye Heart Charm Pendant Solid 14K Yellow White Rose Gold Platinum or Sterling Silver

from $39.99

Model Wearing Dome Bezel Diamond Stud Earring

Domed Bezel Set Natural Diamond Stud Earrings .06 CTW 14K Rose Gold

Domed Natural Diamond Bezel-Set Stud Earrings Solid 14K Rose White Yellow Gold Platinum or Sterling

from $261.99

Model wearing Natural Turquoise Bar Bracelet in 14K Yellow Gold

Natural Turquoise Bar Bracelet 14K Rose Gold

Dainty Natural Turquoise Bar Adjustable Bracelet 14K Rose White Yellow Gold or Sterling

from $148.99

Model Wearing Freshwater Cultured Solitaire Pearl Adjustable Necklace in Solid 14K Yellow Gold

Freshwater Cultured Solitaire Pearl 16-18" Necklace 14K Yellow Gold Necklace Ethical Sustainable Fine Jewelry Storyteller by Vintage Magnality

Dainty Freshwater Cultured Solitaire Pearl 16-18" Necklace Solid 14K Yellow White Gold

from $421.99

Model Wearing Crescent Moon Natural Diamond Charm Pendant Solid 14K Yellow Gold

Crescent Moon Natural Diamond Charm Pendant Solid 14K Yellow Gold

Crescent Moon Natural Diamond Charm Pendant Solid 14K Yellow White Rose Gold

from $407.99

Angel Wing and Cherub Fine Jewelry Perfect for Gift Giving

Natural Diamond Angel Wing Stud Earrings in Solid 14K Rose Gold

Angel Wing Natural Diamond Stud Earrings Solid 14K Rose Yellow White Gold or Sterling

from $273.99

A personalized charm collection on yellow gold threader chain bracelet or necklace

14K Yellow Gold or Yellow Gold Filled 1.1 MM Adjustable Charm Threader Cable 6"-8" or 16"-22" Chain Bracelet or Necklace Storyteller by Vintage Magnality

Wear Everyday® Adjustable Charm Threader 1.1. MM Cable Chain 6-8" Bracelet or 16-22" Necklace

from $41.99

Leaf Natural Diamond Ear Climber Earrings in 14K Yellow Gold on Model Rendering

Leaf Natural Diamond Ear Climber Earrings in 14K White Gold

Roman Leaf Natural Diamond Ear Climber Earrings Solid 14K Yellow White Rose Gold

from $384.99

Gorgeous earrings perfect for Valentine's Day Gifts

Heart Envelope Stud Earrings in 14K Yellow Gold

Send Your Love Heart Envelope Stud Earrings Solid 14K Rose White Yellow Gold or Silver

from $82.99

Diamond Stud Earrings

Natural Diamond Stud Earrings Four Prong One Quarter CTW 14K White Gold

Natural Diamond Stud Earrings 4-Prong 14K White Gold 1/4 to 2 CTW

from $456.99

Micro Natural Diamond Bezel-Set Stud Earrings on model

Micro Bezel-Set Natural Diamond Stud Earrings in 14K White Gold 2.5 MM Pair or Single

Micro Natural Diamond Bezel-Set Earrings Single or Pair 14K Yellow White or Rose Gold 1.25 MM to 2.5 MM

from $149.99

Heart Toggle Clasp & Paperclip Style Chain 6" Bracelet Solid 14K Yellow Gold

Heart Toggle Clasp & Paperclip Style Chain 6" Bracelet Solid 14K Rose Gold

Heart Toggle Clasp & Paperclip Style Chain 6" Bracelet Solid 14K Yellow White Rose Gold

from $463.99

All stacked up with our solid gold rings featuring our Fabulous Modern Freshwater Cultured Pearl Ring

Fabulous Modern Freshwater Cultured Pearl Ring Solid 14K Yellow White Rose Gold Sizes 5-7

from $384.99

Cupid Heart Arrow 1/8 CTW Natural Diamond 16" Elongated Paperclip Chain Necklace in 14K Yellow Gold

Cupid Heart Arrow 1/8 CTW Natural Diamond 16" Elongated Paperclip Chain Necklace in 14K Yellow Gold

Cupid Heart Arrow Natural Diamond 16" Elongated Paperclip Chain Necklace 14K Yellow White Rose Gold or Sterling

from $475.99

Engrave Me Natural Diamond Heart Charm Pendant in 14K Yellow Gold

Engrave Me Heart Natural Diamond Charm Pendant in 14K White Gold or Sterling Silver

Engrave Me Natural Diamond Heart Charm Pendant 14K White Yellow Rose Gold or Silver

from $107.99

Solid 14K White Gold Herringbone Necklace Layered with Lab-Grown Diamond Line Tennis Necklace

Herringbone Solid Yellow 14K Gold Lobster Clasp Bracelet Necklace Chains

2.8 MM Flexible Herringbone Necklace Bracelet Chain Solid 14K Yellow White Gold 7" 16" 18" 20" 24"

from $451.99

Pearl Drop Dangle Earrings Solid 14K Yellow Gold

Cultured Akoya Pearl Bezel Diamond Drop Dangle Earrings Solid 14K Yellow Gold

Cultured Akoya Pearl Bezel Diamond Drop Dangle Earrings Solid 14K Yellow White Rose Gold

from $408.99

Model wearing Chain Link Earrings with Diamond Baguette Ear Climber Storyteller by Vintage Magnality

Chain Link Dreams Earrings in 14K Yellow Gold

Chain Link Dreams Drop Dangle Earrings Solid 14K Yellow Rose White Gold or Silver

from $109.99

Celtic Trinity Ring in 14K Yellow Gold shown with other Symbolic Jewelry Pieces

Celtic Trinity Ring in 14K White Gold or Sterling Silver

Celtic-Inspired Trinity Ring Solid 14K White Yellow Rose Gold or Silver

from $95.99

Model wearing our Cool Kid Natural Diamond Ear Cuff Earring in Solid 14K Gold

Cool Kid Natural Diamond 1/6 CTW in 14K Yellow Gold

Cool Kid Natural Diamond Ear Cuff Earring Solid 14K White Rose Yellow Gold

from $411.99

Diamond Smiley Face Charm Pendant 14K Yellow Gold 302® Fine Jewelry Vintage Magnality

Diamond Smiley Face Charm Pendant 14K Yellow Gold 302® Fine Jewelry Vintage Magnality

Diamond Smiley Face Charm Pendant 14K Yellow Rose White or Sterling

from $321.99

1
2
3