Storyteller Fine Jewelry Wear Everyday™ Everywhere

302® Fine Jewelry

210 items

We are a preferred 302® Fine Jewelry Retailer, shop the designer collection here!

Birthstone Gemstone Jewelry

Birthstone Gemstone Jewelry

47 items

Looking for the perfect birthstone or gemstone jewelry piece to wear or give as a thoughtful gift? Look no further!...

Celtic Irish Heritage Jewelry

Celtic Irish Heritage Jewelry

8 items

Get ready for St. Patrick's Day and celebrate your Celtic and Irish heritage by wearing your favorite Celtic inspired symbols...

Solid 14K Gold or Sterling Silver Chains Necklaces and Bracelets


14 items

Get ready to layer up! Are you looking for the perfect Wear Everyday™ necklace or bracelet chain in solid 14K...

Charms & Pendants Perfect for Gift Giving

Charms Pendants Dangles

50 items

Shop Vintage Magnality's exquisite collection of Charms and Pendants, where elegance meets craftsmanship. Discover a captivating array of fine jewelry pieces...

Diamond Earrings Shown on Model Make the Perfect Holiday Gift

Diamond Earrings

59 items

Shop Vintage Magnality's Diamond Earrings collection, where timeless elegance meets dazzling brilliance. These fine jewelry pieces are meticulously crafted to enhance...

Drop Dangle Bezel Set Diamond Earrings

Drop Dangle Earrings

19 items

Shop Vintage Magnality's exquisite Drop Dangle Earrings Collection, where timeless elegance meets contemporary sophistication. Crafted with meticulous attention to detail...

Diamond Single Initial Earrings 14K Yellow Gold


142 items

Shop Vintage Magnality's exquisite Earrings Collection, where timeless elegance meets contemporary allure. Discover a stunning array of fine jewelry pieces crafted to...

Holiday Gifts for Her Made Easy with our Curated Collection of Fine Jewelry Pieces

Fine Jewelry Gifts For Her

43 items

Shop online at Lake Forest's Vintage Magnality using our Fine Jewelry Gifts For Her Gift Guide, your ultimate destination for...

Gift Cards

Gift Cards

1 item

The perfect gift for any jewelry lover!

Natural Blue Sapphire Huggie Hoop Earring in Yellow Gold

Hoop & Huggie Earrings

26 items

Shop Vintage Magnality's exquisite Hoop & Huggie Earring Collection – a celebration of timeless elegance and contemporary style. Dive into a...

Shop our collection of Initial Jewelry! Initial Earrings, initial necklaces, initial bracelets and initial rings

Initial Jewelry

24 items

Initial jewelry is an all time favorite personalized jewelry gift!  It's thoughtful, personalized and a popular style to wear.  Whether...

Lab-Grown Diamond Fine Jewelry

Lab-Grown Diamond Fine Jewelry

29 items

Shop Vintage Magnality's exquisite Lab-Grown Diamond Fine Jewelry Collection, where timeless elegance meets sustainable luxury. Discover a stunning array of...

Shop our Pearl Fine Jewelry Collection

Pearl Jewelry

35 items

Shop our modern day pearl classics!  Pearls are one of June's amazing birthstones but are loved by many more. What...

Diamond Stackable Rings Shop Our Rings Now!


98 items

Don't know your ring size? Use our Ring Sizer to help you find the best fit for you, shop here.  ...

Stud earring collection

Stud Earrings

68 items

Shop Vintage Magnality's exquisite Stud Earring Collection.  Elevate your style with timeless elegance and unparalleled craftsmanship. Each piece in this meticulously...



31 items

All of these pieces are vintage, one-of-a-kind finds! I love the history, charm, romance and character of vintage jewelry.  Thinking...

Youth Fine Jewelry Collection

Youth Fine Jewelry Collection

16 items

Introducing our exquisite Youth Fine Jewelry Collection, specially crafted to capture the essence of youthful elegance and charm. This collection...

Zodiac Fine Jewelry Collection

Zodiac Fine Jewelry Collection

6 items

Zodiac fine jewelry makes the perfect personalized jewelry gift.  We have so many great jewelry pieces in our Zodiac Collection,...